Judge Judy’s Twice-Told Love Story Will Leave You in Awe

When Judge Judy Sheindlin divorced her husband, she was going through a very tough time. But their separation didn’t last long, and later she shared why she chose to marry him again.

Judge Judy Sheindlin is famous for being a TV judge and has a background as a prosecutor and family court judge. She is married to Jerry Sheindlin, who is also a lawyer and a former judge.

Judy and her husband have always supported each other in their legal jobs. When Jerry, who was a judge in New York, got an offer to join “The People’s Court,” he asked Judy for advice.

In an interview, Jerry said, “She is the one who told me I should do it.” He added that he wouldn’t have accepted the role if Judy had doubts about it.

Even with Judy’s big success on TV, Jerry wasn’t worried about competition. He said, “I think that behind every great woman, there is a man. […] But I also heard that behind every great man, there is a woman.”

Jerry started leaving his job as a Supreme Court judge when he began filming for “The People’s Court.” This new job, where he handled about 10 cases a day for two days a week, was much easier than the 150 cases he used to manage.

Judy and Jerry’s relationship has always been tied to their shared legal careers. They first met in a bar after Jerry had just defended a murder case.

While talking to a reporter, Judy walked in, pointed at him, and asked, “And who is this?” Jerry replied, “Lady, get your finger out of my face.” Since then, they have been together.

While Jerry enjoyed watching Judy’s success on TV, he joked, “If my show takes off and I beat her, I am contacting Hollywood to remake ‘Sleeping With the Enemy.’”

Their relationship grew with their boldness and humor. After a year together, Judy hinted at marriage, but Jerry had some doubts.

Getty Images

He said, “Why does the government have to dictate our relationship? It’s just a piece of paper. We’re already committed to each other.” Instead of pushing him, Judy suggested that if Jerry wanted them to live together, he should ask her dad for permission. Not wanting to face her father, Jerry chose to set a wedding date, and they married in 1977.

Though they were very committed to each other, their relationship hit a rough patch in 1990 when they divorced. The strain came after Judy’s father passed away, which put her under a lot of emotional stress. However, they remarried just a year later.

Getty Images

Jerry shared his feelings about that tough time, saying, “I missed her presence the very first week we were separated. It was strange not seeing her every day.”

Meanwhile, Judy admitted she enjoyed being married and missed Jerry when they were apart. She believed there was something special about sharing life as a couple.

After they got back together, Judy talked about their brief split in an interview. When asked why she decided to reunite with Jerry in 1991, she said, “That’s a long story, but the end is: I found that most men were alike.”

Judy shared her views on the differences between men and women. She said men have different basic needs. They like being cared for, receiving affection, and having their personal space. If they are fed, shown love, and given room to do their own thing, they are usually happy.

Getty Images

She has always been open about the dynamics of her long marriage with Jerry. In a January 2024 interview, she talked about how they have kept their relationship strong for nearly 50 years.

“You don’t spend 24 hours together because that’s deadly,” she explained, stressing the importance of personal space. Judy added, “Jerry just celebrated his 90th birthday, and I still like looking at him when he walks in the room—that’s a key.”

Judy, who will turn 82 on October 21, 2024, has always talked about how important it is to look good as you age. However, when it comes to Jerry, she doesn’t need to remind him—he already knows how to stay healthy.

“He loves himself dearly. Jerry is almost ten years older than I am, but I think his goal is to outlive me. He takes very good care of himself,” said the TV star, who once had a mini-stroke while filming a show.

Judy and Jerry’s lasting bond continues to win over fans, both on and off the screen. In a heartfelt Facebook post, she shared a picture of them together, which received a lot of love from followers.

One person commented, “You and your husband look so good together. Love your smiles,” while another said, “You look amazing. Love your common sense judgments.”

Judy Sheindlin and Jerry Sheindlin’s long-lasting relationship shows the power of love, respect, and shared laughter. After nearly five decades together, their bond remains strong, proving that true companionship can last through all of life’s challenges.

I Woke up with a Stranger’s Baby in My Arms and a Note in Her Little Hands

They say miracles come when you least expect them. But as I sat in the park, drowsy from another failed fertility treatment, I never imagined waking up with a newborn baby in my arms and a note in her tiny hands that would shatter my world into a million pieces.

Some days change your life forever. For me, it was an ordinary Tuesday in September when my world turned upside down. I’m Grace, 35 years old, and for eight years, my husband Joshua and I have tried desperately to have a child. We’ve endured countless treatments, shed more tears than I can count, and watched our dreams slip away month after month…😔💔

A woman holding a plastic doll of a newborn baby | Source: Midjourney

A woman holding a plastic doll of a newborn baby | Source: Midjourney

That afternoon, I had just left another disappointing appointment at the fertility clinic. Dr. Rivera’s words still echoed in my head, “I’m sorry, Mrs. Thompson. The latest round wasn’t successful.”

The drive home was a blur. I pulled over twice, unable to see through my tears. As if mocking my situation, the radio played a commercial for diapers, and I had to turn it off.

Eight years of this emotional rollercoaster had taken its toll on both of us. Joshua and I barely talked about it anymore, the silence between us growing with each failed attempt.

A sad woman in a car | Source: Midjourney

A sad woman in a car | Source: Midjourney

I couldn’t face going home right away.

Joshua would be there, trying to be strong for both of us, and I couldn’t bear to see the hope die in his eyes one more time.

So I went to Riverside Park, our quiet haven in the chaos of the city.

“Just need to clear my head,” I mumbled to myself, settling onto a sun-warmed bench. The medication always made me drowsy, and before I knew it, my eyes were drifting closed.

A wooden bench in a park | Source: Unsplash

A wooden bench in a park | Source: Unsplash

The gentle cooing of pigeons and the distant laughter of children must have roused me from my medication-induced slumber.

As my eyes fluttered open, adjusting to the late afternoon sun, I realized everything had changed.

In my arms was a sleeping newborn baby girl, swaddled in a pale yellow blanket. For a moment, I thought I was dreaming.

A baby swaddled in a pale yellow blanket | Source: Midjourney

A baby swaddled in a pale yellow blanket | Source: Midjourney

“Oh God, oh God!” I jerked upright, trying not to jostle the infant even as panic seized my chest. My eyes darted wildly around the park. “Hello? Please, is anyone there? This baby… whose baby is this?”

That’s when I noticed the note, clutched in her tiny fist like a lifeline. With trembling fingers, I carefully unfolded the paper. The handwriting was rushed, almost frantic:

“Her name’s Andrea. I can’t take care of her anymore. Now she’s yours. Forgive me for everything. Don’t look for me. You’ll never find me. Take care of her. Goodbye.”

A woman holding a piece of paper | Source: Midjourney

A woman holding a piece of paper | Source: Midjourney

My heart was pounding so hard I could barely breathe.

Next to the bench was a diaper bag, packed with everything a newborn would need — formula, diapers, a few onesies, and even a small stuffed rabbit with a pink bow.

I fumbled for my phone, nearly dropping it as I dialed Joshua.

“Grace? Aren’t you supposed to be at the clinic?” he was alarmed.

“Josh, I need you. Now. Something’s happened. Someone left a baby with me in the park. She was… she was just sleeping in my arms. I don’t know what to do.”

A woman holding a phone | Source: Unsplash

A woman holding a phone | Source: Unsplash

There was a long pause. “Don’t move. I’m coming right now.”

“Josh, I’m scared,” I whispered, looking down at the peaceful face of this mysterious baby. “What if someone’s looking for her? What if something’s wrong?”

“Stay calm, honey. I’ll be there in ten minutes. Just… just keep her safe.”

While I waited, I couldn’t help but study the little one’s perfect little face. She couldn’t have been more than a few weeks old. Her skin was so soft, her tiny pink fingers curled into fists. Despite the insanity of the situation, something in my heart felt… weird.

A baby fast asleep | Source: Unsplash

A baby fast asleep | Source: Unsplash

An elderly woman walked by, smiling at us. “What a beautiful baby,” she said. “How old is she?”

My throat tightened. “Just a few weeks.”

“Treasure every moment,” she advised. “They grow up so fast.”

If only she knew.

An older lady talking to a young woman | Source: Midjourney

An older lady talking to a young woman | Source: Midjourney

Joshua’s car screeched to a halt at the park entrance fifteen minutes later. He ran toward us, his face brimming with confusion and concern.

“Oh my God,” he whispered, staring at the sleeping little angel. “Is this real?”

“I don’t know what to do,” I said, tears finally spilling over. “We need to go to the police, right?”

A startled woman | Source: Midjourney

A startled woman | Source: Midjourney

He nodded, running a hand through his hair, a nervous habit I knew well. “Yeah, we do. But first, is she okay? Does she need anything?”

As if on cue, Andrea began to stir, her face scrunching up. Before she could cry, I found myself swaying her gently, the way I’d always imagined I would with our own baby.

“Shh, it’s okay, little one,” I whispered. “We’ll figure this out.”

Grayscale of a woman holding a baby | Source: Unsplash

Grayscale of a woman holding a baby | Source: Unsplash

Joshua watched us, confused and happy at the same time. “You look so natural with her, Grace,” he said softly.

“Don’t,” I warned. “This isn’t… we can’t think like that. We need to do the right thing.”

He nodded, but I could see the longing in his eyes. The same longing I’d been fighting all these years.

“Let’s go to the police station,” he said finally. “They’ll know what to do.”

A sad man | Source: Midjourney

A sad man | Source: Midjourney

The police station buzzed with activity. As officers pored over security footage from the park, I noticed the face of the woman who abandoned the baby was frustratingly blurry, thwarting attempts to identify her.

Meanwhile, social services were notified, and I found myself repeating my story countless times.

“No, I didn’t see anyone… Yes, I was asleep… The note was in her hand when I woke up…”

A kind officer named Brooke brought us coffee and a bottle of milk for Andrea. “You’re doing the right thing,” she assured us. “We’ll figure out where she belongs.”

A lady police officer smiling | Source: Pexels

A lady police officer smiling | Source: Pexels

Through it all, I couldn’t let go of Andrea. She needed a diaper change, and Officer Brooke directed me to a small bathroom.

That’s when everything changed again.

As I carefully changed the baby’s diaper, I saw it — a small, distinctive birthmark on the inside of her thigh.

My heart stopped.

It was identical to Joshua’s, the same mark I’d traced with my finger countless times over our years together.

A woman changing a baby's diaper | Source: Pexels

A woman changing a baby’s diaper | Source: Pexels

The world turned upside down. And memories flashed through my mind. Joshua working late last year, the strange calls he’d take in another room, and the distance that had grown between us.

I walked back out to the waiting area on shaky legs. Joshua was talking to an officer, his back to me.

“Josh,” I called out. “I need to show you something.”

In a quiet corner of the station, I showed him the birthmark. The color drained from his face in an instant.

A stunned woman | Source: Midjourney

A stunned woman | Source: Midjourney

“Is there something you need to tell me?” I asked, my teary eyes boring into his. “Are you hiding something from me, Josh?”

He sank into a chair, head in his hands. “Grace, I… I can explain.”

“Then explain.”

“Remember last year, when I was working late on the Miller account?” He couldn’t meet my eyes.

“Tell me… I’m all ears.”

An anxious man | Source: Midjourney

An anxious man | Source: Midjourney

“There was this woman, Kira. She was going through a divorce, and we started talking. She knew about our struggles to have a baby…”

“Did you sleep with her?”

His silence was answer enough.

“It was just a few weeks,” he finally confessed. “We ended it. I never knew she was pregnant. I swear, Grace, I had no idea.”

A romantic couple in bed | Source: Pexels

A romantic couple in bed | Source: Pexels

I felt like I was underwater, everything muffled and distant. “While I was taking hormones and going through painful procedures, you were having an AFFAIR?”

“I’m so sorry,” he whispered. “I never meant for any of this to happen.”

I looked down at Andrea, still sleeping peacefully, unaware of the chaos she’d brought into our lives.

“How could you do this to us?” I cried, staring at Joshua… the man I loved. And trusted unconditionally.

An emotional woman | Source: Midjourney

An emotional woman | Source: Midjourney

“I was lost,” he said, his eyes pleading. “Watching you go through all those treatments, seeing how much pain you were in… I couldn’t handle it. Kira was just… there.”

“And now her baby… your baby… is here. With us.”

The DNA test later confirmed what we already knew. Andrea was Joshua’s daughter.

Close-up of a newborn baby | Source: Unsplash

Close-up of a newborn baby | Source: Unsplash

That night, in our too-quiet house, with Andrea asleep in a hastily purchased bassinet, I finally broke down.

“Do you know what it’s been like? Everyone questioning why I couldn’t give you a child. The pitying looks. The suggestions to ‘just relax and it’ll happen.’ And all this time while you…”

Joshua reached for me, but I backed away. “Don’t. Just… don’t.”

A heartbroken woman | Source: Midjourney

A heartbroken woman | Source: Midjourney

“I know I messed up, Grace. But please, can we try to work through this? For Andrea’s sake?”

I looked at the sleeping baby. Despite everything, my heart swelled with love for her. She was innocent in all of this.

“I don’t know how to forgive you,” I admitted.

“I don’t know how to forgive myself,” he replied.

A distressed man | Source: Midjourney

A distressed man | Source: Midjourney

Days turned into weeks. We started therapy, trying to rebuild what was broken. Some days were harder than others.

My sister thought I was crazy for staying. “He cheated on you, Grace! File for divorce!”

But as I held Andrea each night, watching her tiny chest rise and fall, I knew it wasn’t that simple. Love rarely is.

A woman carrying a baby | Source: Pexels

A woman carrying a baby | Source: Pexels

“I don’t know if I can ever trust you again,” I told Joshua one evening as we sat on opposite ends of the couch.

He nodded, his eyes glistening. “I understand. But I’m not giving up on us.”

It’s been months since the stormy revelation of my husband’s affair and the baby that resulted from it. As I rock Andrea to sleep every night, I realize that life doesn’t always follow the path we imagined. Sometimes it takes unexpected turns, bringing us gifts wrapped in challenges.

A heartbroken man holding his head | Source: Midjourney

A heartbroken man holding his head | Source: Midjourney

Yes, Joshua betrayed me, and that pain won’t fade overnight. But looking down at this precious little girl in my arms, I know I can’t walk away. Not from her, and maybe not from us either.

Healing takes time. Trust needs to be rebuilt, slowly and steadily. But as Andrea’s tiny fingers wrap around mine, I feel a glimmer of hope. Perhaps this isn’t the family we planned for, but it’s ours now. And maybe, just maybe, we can find our way to a new kind of happiness… one day at a time.

Grayscale of a woman holding a baby | Source: Pexels

Grayscale of a woman holding a baby | Source: Pexels

This work is inspired by real events and people, but it has been fictionalized for creative purposes. Names, characters, and details have been changed to protect privacy and enhance the narrative. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, or actual events is purely coincidental and not intended by the author.

The author and publisher make no claims to the accuracy of events or the portrayal of characters and are not liable for any misinterpretation. This story is provided “as is,” and any opinions expressed are those of the characters and do not reflect the views of the author or publisher.

Related Posts

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*